Charlie Cummings, Founder and Managing Broker at Innovate Commercial Real Estate

The Zelnik Exchange, Episode 045Hosted by Cory ZelnikNovember 12, 202637 minute listen
The Zelnik Exchange
Introduction

Charlie Cummings, Founder and Managing Broker of Innovate Commercial Real Estate, sat down with Cory Zelnik, founder of Zelnik & Company in New York, for episode 045 of The Zelnik Exchange.

They talk all things brokerage and AI: how Charlie went from airport consulting to commercial real estate, the first steps he took with AI, how a contract that took 40 minutes now takes eight, how clients follow their deal in a Client Portal, what restaurant build outs cost in Denver, and why boutique firms have the biggest advantage with this technology.

How did Charlie go from aviation to commercial real estate?

Cory Zelnik: Welcome again to The Zelnik Exchange podcast. I'm your host, Cory Zelnik. Today I have the pleasure of spending some time with Charlie Cummings, the founder and managing broker at Innovate Commercial Real Estate out of Denver, Colorado. We're going to talk all things brokerage and AI. Welcome to the show, Charlie.

Charlie Cummings: Thank you, Cory. I appreciate it.

Cory Zelnik: Today I think it's going to be about learning new things, and you're going to be the teacher. Before we dive into AI, tell me about the aviation management you studied in school and how that brings you to today.

Charlie Cummings: I always wanted to be a commercial airline pilot. In my first year in college I got licensed and decided it was not really what I wanted to do, and I'm so glad I didn't pursue that path. The alternative was to become a consultant. I consulted for airports on environmental and planning studies for nine years. We wrote the reports so the FAA could say, yes, you can go build that, and here's what you have to do to mitigate the consequences of those improvements.

Charlie Cummings: I remember in one of my first interviews my boss said, you're going to work on things that nobody cares about. Back then I thought, whatever, it's a job, it's stable. But after nine years I realized this was not the best and highest version of Charlie.

Cory Zelnik: All the things nobody cared about, but at the end of the day they really were important. So you do that for nine years. When do you launch into the real estate world?

Charlie Cummings: In 2016. I had a friend at the KW downtown office in Denver who said, you should check this out. I got licensed, did residential for a year, and realized it was not really the right room. I liked the commercial side. I was talking to business owners, and there was a commercial team in that office, so I got to experience a little of what that was like. I didn't come from a big shop. I had a mentor, but I didn't have a group of people doing a lot of deals, so I learned through a lot of trial and error.

Charlie Cummings: Fast forward to 2023 and Innovate CRE. I looked at going on my own or joining a local boutique, and I realized, you've always had these ideas, even in airports, of how to do things better. You're always the person in the room saying, hold on a second, before we just go with the status quo. Innovate means to do something different. It's not just about tech. If 90 percent are doing this, what's the other 10 percent doing, or the 1 percent?

What was the first step with AI?

Cory Zelnik: AI starts everybody's day in some capacity now. What was the first move? Claude, ChatGPT, Perplexity?

Charlie Cummings: It was Claude. What happened this summer is I hired an intern, somebody who wanted to get into the space. His brother had a marketing company that was just launching, and he uses Claude Code to build all his websites. That was the first decision: hiring somebody who was already further into it than me, not an expensive consulting firm. Once I got the keys to it, my mind just exploded. I can just talk to this thing and it can do this work, do it better than I could have, and keep improving.

Charlie Cummings: People think what I've built is crazy, but it has been three months of Claude Code. It integrates with all of my Google Workspace, and it can integrate with Outlook or whatever you're using for your email and your drive. That's really important.

Charlie Cummings: If you're going to get started today, first pick one, whether it's Gemini or ChatGPT, and start testing it on basic, routine things like emails and tracking. Can it write a letter of intent for me? I don't write letters of intent anymore. I review them.

Charlie Cummings: Take one contract to buy and sell. Before AI that would take me 30 to 40 minutes, maybe an hour. Copy and paste, pull the assessor record, and so on. Now I can say, this buyer is going to buy 123 Main Street, please update the contract, put it in the drive folder, and let me review it before it goes out for signature. That can be done in eight minutes. Compound all the tasks commercial real estate brokers do over and over, and it adds up to a huge time savings.

How did Charlie build his business before AI?

Cory Zelnik: Step back a little bit. What were you doing before? Give me a little of your story.

Charlie Cummings: A lot of my business was referral based, because I started in a residential office. From those referrals other deals came, whether it was a retail or office acquisition, a lease, or a landlord assignment. I kept building momentum on referrals and then building more specialty. The basics of the business haven't really changed. It's how I'm doing it now.

Charlie Cummings: In the past I did all my own marketing, all my own broker opinions of value and offering memorandums. I didn't have a marketing team. Of course you put a listing on the MLS, CoStar and Crexi, but then how do we do off market? I was doing all of it very inefficiently, like a lot of brokers. It was almost luck. You put it on the right site and hope the right eyes find it.

Charlie Cummings: Now it's, let's reverse engineer that. I don't want to guess anymore. Whether it's a tenant or buyer assignment or a landlord or seller assignment, everything is mapped out before you engage with me. You know exactly how it's going to work and who the likely buyers or tenants are before we sign. We put that in a form the client can digest, as opposed to, just take my word for it.

Cory Zelnik: How long were you brokering commercial before it became technology driven?

Charlie Cummings: About seven and a half years without AI. Really it's the last five months that we started, and the last two that we've been optimizing what we do.

Cory Zelnik: And you do sales only?

Charlie Cummings: Sales and leasing. We're about split half and half.

How does AI pull comps and market data?

Cory Zelnik: Through AI, are you grabbing all the necessary data, the comps and things like that?

Charlie Cummings: The data is changing so rapidly. Lease comps are still the toughest part of the business. If it's assessor and public record information, we have a connector with Terrakotta, which is huge. I can say, Claude, find me every retail building under 5,000 square feet that traded in the last 12 months, get me the contacts and do the research. It does its thing, and within about 10 minutes I have that information.

Cory Zelnik: We have that too through various programs. But when you want to know what the 5,000 square foot tenant paid in rent, you can't get anywhere near that. I've been doing leasing my whole career, and for some reason that information is treated like gold.

Charlie Cummings: We work with CompStak, and it is still hard to get that information.

Charlie Cummings: On disclosure, when I close a deal I want to make sure the client is good with publishing the success story. If I publish the actual details, not just who I worked with but that I did the lease for a 10 year term, that's what AI picks up for future business. If a client would prefer I not share it, we talk about it, because most of the clients I work with, I want to do multiple deals with. It's not a one off.

Cory Zelnik: It depends on the relationship you have. Most retailers want you to say, we just signed at 123 Main Street, grand opening next Tuesday. They don't want you to say what they pay in rent.

Charlie Cummings: Right. It's a balance. The nice thing with retail is they love the exposure.

What does a restaurant build out cost in Denver?

Cory Zelnik: The cost of doing business here in New York is tough, and so are the rules and regulations the city imposes.

Charlie Cummings: In Denver too.

Cory Zelnik: Just curious, what are you seeing?

Charlie Cummings: I can tell you that in Denver, for about 2,300 square feet, it's about a million dollars to take a gray shell to a complete build out of a fast casual concept. That's just the build out, not the furniture, fixtures and equipment.

Cory Zelnik: Here it's way more than that. On a 2,000 square foot unit it can be two and a half to three million dollars, and every deal takes a year from lease through planning.

Charlie Cummings: Wow. We've seen some ground up construction projects here for national fast casual brands, and the new prototypes are really nice.

How do you win new business with AI?

Cory Zelnik: So tell me how you win new business with AI.

Charlie Cummings: A couple of things. One is being found. People are using these tools to find us. I'm getting about three to five inbound leads a week. Of those, maybe two are convertible, but people are going into ChatGPT and asking, I need a property or a space for this. Then they look at reviews. We have 82 five star reviews and that keeps going up, so we leverage Google a lot. In the boutique model, that's typically how they find us. They're Googling it or using AI, and it all links together.

Charlie Cummings: The second is site selection. We have a 17 acre site in Commerce City that we're marketing to national retailers, and we're negotiating with a few right now. I took everything that used to live in a spreadsheet and put it on a simple board filtered by status: open, not contacted, negotiating. My client can go into each card and see who we're talking to, who the rep is, and whether there's a broker or it's direct to that national tenant. It's all in one place.

Cory Zelnik: So you're essentially sharing a CRM with the client, as opposed to the old days of filling out the boxes and sending over the report.

Charlie Cummings: Exactly. Instead of death by a thousand emails. If they click on a card, it opens the actual letter of intent or the prototype, so their general contractor can pull it and get us an updated bid. Our meeting notes are linked too. I could do the same for any retailer: here's how we're going to do your site selection on the ground.

Charlie Cummings: Then we go one step deeper, to the off market opportunities. What about space that has not been publicly listed on Crexi or CoStar, where we know there's a box of that size in the center? We reach out to the landlord and say, I have this tenant and here's what we're doing. And the demographic work, most of the census data is a free connection right into Claude, so you can look at drive times and all those metrics.

Cory Zelnik: Some of it is me being old fashioned and some of it is New York being a little different. At the end of the day it's still blocking and tackling. You've got to make the phone calls. You've got to go feel and touch these things before you present.

Charlie Cummings: What I was trying to figure out last week is sourcing a deal. Most commercial real estate brokers do the same thing. What if I had every potential tenant teed up before you sign? Look at every business in the area, find any research showing a company that wants to be in this market. What could take a week of back and forth is condensed into hours of research that's working while you're doing something else.

Why do boutique brokerages have the advantage with AI?

Cory Zelnik: So you're about five or six months into this?

Charlie Cummings: Yes, and the last two have been supercharged. I can talk to Claude and it starts doing tasks for me. I listen to what clients say. When somebody calls with a problem or a challenge, my mind immediately goes to, can I build this, and can I build it for other people too?

Charlie Cummings: Owning the product is the most liberating feeling. I've talked to a lot of prop tech companies. Sometimes they have something that connects well and sometimes they don't. Now I think, I don't need that subscription. I can build my own. I replaced my scheduling tool in 20 minutes.

Charlie Cummings: I don't want to sell this and repackage it, because that's a whole different ball game. My best and highest use is being a broker, using the technology to source deals quicker and serve more clients. For boutique shops, you have the biggest advantage of anybody with this technology, bigger than any big company. It's built for shops like yours and mine, where you can make a change in 10 minutes and it's done.

Cory Zelnik: It's the same thing with social media. The only thing the big four or five companies ever put out are press releases.

Is it turning into deals, and what comes next?

Cory Zelnik: Deals take time to get done. How do you feel from a deal making perspective? At the end of the day, you've got to make deals.

Charlie Cummings: Given where we are in the market, it's tough, and I've seen a lot of things stall out. My pipeline is getting healthier. I've taken over listings before, ahead of the AI work, and gotten them done, so I do have success doing things differently. Now I can put a name and a process on it and brand it, as opposed to, Charlie's just really good at finding tenants.

Charlie Cummings: One of the things clients have given us good feedback on is the Client Portal. Whether you're a tenant, landlord or seller, you have a one click dashboard. Everybody likes Uber because they can see where their car is. Wouldn't it be great if the anxiety of a deal could be tracked in one place? We've received the inspection, we're 30 days out, and here's what's left for you, as opposed to going through a bunch of emails. They can still call me and text me. That's not going away. I just have more time for the in person work and less on the back end admin.

Charlie Cummings: In all the chaos we're seeing right now, I've had more clarity and vision about where we're headed. Deals will take longer, so how can I re engineer the process to be a little shorter than the average cycle?

Cory Zelnik: I like the story and I like the trajectory for you. Get it out on social media, promote yourself, promote what you're doing.

Charlie Cummings: You can give people a lot of these secrets and they still won't do it. Change is hard. The other thing I'm looking at is succession planning. Say you're a broker who wants to retire in five years and doesn't want to learn any of this. You team up with Innovate CRE. You go out and have your face time, do the showings and negotiate. Everything is in our platform, you still get a part of that deal, and you don't have to rebuild a single thing.

Cory Zelnik: I think it's amazing. I want you to come back and do this again so we can see how it has progressed. Charlie, I appreciate your time. Thank you so much.

Charlie Cummings: Thanks, Cory.

This transcript of The Zelnik Exchange, Episode 045 has been edited for length and clarity. The full conversation is in the episode, hosted by Cory Zelnik.